One of the great lies in sports as follows, “Nothing matters if you don’t win a championship.”
Guess what. Most people don’t win championships.
We must, as fans, instinctively know this. Players, especially guys who never won a championship (sup C-Webb and Charles Barkley) must instinctively know this. Yet we continue to hear it, repeat it, believe it.
But what else do we do? We hope. And when we watch a regular season game and our team is down ten, but comes back to win–we erupt. Emotionally we sour, we slap five, we (even those of us who would NEVER) dance.
Those sorts of moments of ineffable glee matter, even if there is no championship. One team out of over 30 teams each year will win a championship. Big market teams can spend more (and damn well DO spend more) than small markets. Teams with a winning tradition have less trouble bringing guys into town–as do teams in fantastic cities like New York.
Setting aside journeymen who get championships deep on some bench somewhere–most guys will never win a championship. A greater percentage of teams will win than the percentage of individuals. This is even more certain in the NCAA. In the NCAA Men’s B-Ball tourney nearly 70 teams go into the bracket. Only one of those teams will be a champion. See previous notes about tradition and money and you’ll notice a lot of the same schools hitting the final four with more regularity than, say, my school (UNT) which celebrates hardest when they simply MAKE the tourney.
In NCAA Football you really have zero shot at a championship. Out of the over 120 division 1A squads, only a select handful are even eligible for the championship. Just take a look at the broken BCS system and you’ll know that if the creed “Nothing matters but championships” were true–most NCAA football teams may as well shift their funding into some other program. Championships are NOT on the way.
In the NBA you’ve got the same systems in place. Systems that cause small market teams to give away amazing players (Pao Gasol) for pennies because they can’t afford to keep them, and teams like the Lakers snatch them up because they have the money and clout to get away with it. I’m not saying it’s bad for the game, but it’s certainly bad for most of the teams, therefor cities, in the league.
I’m sure that Miami fans are thrilled about last summer, but I also think that if someone like Cuban had orchestrated that type of deal he’d have been investigated in a second. Just look at the chaos when the Mavs wanted to deal and then resign Stackhouse a few years ago. That was them talking internally with a player they already had and they got dumped on. I’m not sure EITHER situation is one I approve of, but I would like to have seen more diligence in both cases by the front offices around the league (including THE front office).
When all is said, most people won’t own a championship. Dirk, a favorite of mine, will probably be among them. I don’t say that because I don’t believe in the Mavs. I say it because it’s really hard to win a championship. It’s impossible to think of one team making it to the biggest stage and both teams not being worthy of rings.
The best team, no matter how cute it is to say, does not always win. The best team isn’t the one that left it all on the floor, because sometimes both teams leave it all out there and someone still has to lose. Dirk is one of the single best playoff performers in NBA history and he’s playing that way so far through 2 games (especially when it counts), but people like Simmons claim that his lack of a ring means that he isn’t in the top tier.
Why? If one other guy on the team was in the same conversation, wouldn’t the Mavs have a championship by now? Is it too much to think that a man can be amazing even if circumstance doesn’t allow him the perfect storm required to claim a championship? Do we really want to give more credit to Kevin Garnett (a great player who is sort of a miserable representative for the NBA) simply because he was one of those guys who jumped ship for an easy chance at a title?
Can’t we also quantify greatness in this way: Dirk could have left to go anywhere for any price (including that Miami team I’d bet), but chose to stay here and finish what he started, even if the finish plays out so much like the start, the middle, and the now.
Kevin Garnett has a ring. Good for him. He got it by chasing it like a mercenary. Next LeBron will do so too. Same for Bosh. These guys might get a title and they will then be elevated above guys like Dirk simply via their jewelry.
But, no matter what ringless fools tell you in their night gigs behind a desk, there is more to life than winning a championship–and some of it starts with how you win a championship, how you lose one, and how you rise above both to be more than either side of the argument.